STYLODEX

12 Brands Like Pendleton for Wool Shirts

By Ash · Last checked October 29, 2026 · We may earn a commission

You want another Pendleton Board Shirt, and the next one is $198. Or you want plaid wool that's sewn in the US, and the Board Shirt is assembled in El Salvador. These are the shirt makers people suggest instead, most recommended first. Prices run from a $49.90 flannel to a $340 Japanese wool blend sewn in the US.

For reference, Pendleton shirts runs $88–$230.

At a glance

BrandShirtsSizesBest for
Woolrich$155–$195S–3XLa checked cotton flannel for less than a Board Shirt
Filson$99–$249XS–3XL; some jackets in Long (tall)a wool guide shirt with Long sizes
Johnson Woolen Mills$99.95–$259.95XS–4XL; Tall in some shirts (tall)Vermont-sewn plaid wool, including Tall sizes
J.Crew$89.50–$168.00Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)a cotton chamois or flannel workshirt under $170
Taylor Stitch$118–$188XS–XXL; chest 36–46half-wool plaid for $30 less than a Board Shirt
Barbour$100–$290Chest 30–52 on the Bedalea tartan shirt with a choice of cuts
3sixteen$175–$285Waists 28–42one long-running Japanese flannel worth paying up for
Faherty$148–$348XS–XXLJapanese flannel you can try on in a store
Uniqlo$49.90–$49.90XXS–XLthree plaid flannels for the price of one Board Shirt
Gitman$250–$325S–XXL; collars 14½–22 (tall)a Tennessee-sewn flannel in your exact collar size
Freenote Cloth$220–$360Waists 29–38a US-sewn western shirt in Japanese denim or wool
Schott NYC$75–$490XS–6XL; chest 32–54 on somea wool-blend CPO shirt for well under $150
  1. Woolrich

    1Woolrich

    woolrich.us
    • $155–$195
    • Similar price
    • S–3XL
    • Ships to US

    Woolrich is the name people put next to Pendleton most often, and its flannels cost less than a Board Shirt. The Button-Down Checked Shirt in Pure Cotton Flannel ($155) is the cheapest way in, and the Warren Checked Shirt ($185) is the step up.

    Here's the catch. Every regular-price shirt in its men's range is cotton, and the Button-Down's flannel is lightweight, where the Board Shirt's wool is midweight. Wool only shows up in its quilted and padded overshirts, which start at $435 and sit closer to jackets.

    Sizes go to 3XL. Free shipping needs $200, above Pendleton's $150 line, and returns close after 30 days rather than 60. If it's the wool you're after, Johnson Woolen Mills is the closer match.

    Best for: a checked cotton flannel for less than a Board Shirt

  2. 2Filson

    filson.com
    • $99–$249
    • Similar price
    • XS–3XL; some jackets in Long (tall)
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Filson's 8-oz. Wool Guide Shirt ($249) is the straight swap for a Board Shirt, if you'll pay $51 more for it. For less, the Alaskan Guide Shirt ($149) is its cotton flannel, brushed on both sides. A box pleat across the back lets you reach and swing without the shirt pulling.

    Start with the Alaskan Guide if you're testing the fit. Filson cuts it in Long sizes from M to 2XL, which helps if you wear Pendleton's Tall. Regular sizes stop at 3XL, though, and Pendleton goes to 5X.

    Free shipping starts at $99, and returns run 30 days. For a wool blend that costs less than either, Schott's CPO shirts start at $125.

    Best for: a wool guide shirt with Long sizes

  3. Johnson Woolen Mills

    3Johnson Woolen Mills

    johnsonwoolenmills.com
    • $99.95–$259.95
    • Similar price
    • XS–4XL; Tall in some shirts (tall)
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Johnson Woolen Mills is the one to pick if you want plaid wool cut and sewn in the US. It's been a family business in Johnson, Vermont, since 1842, and its Wool Button Down Shirt ($169.95) costs less than a Board Shirt.

    The cloth is 85% wool and 15% nylon, at 18 or 20 ounces, and that shirt is cut short to wear untucked. If you tuck in, get the Long Tail Wool Button Down ($169.95 to $199.95) instead. It goes up to 4XL and comes in a Tall version for anyone who wears Pendleton's Tall.

    The trade-off is range. You get a handful of plaids, not racks of them, and free shipping needs $200, so a single shirt ships for $12.99. Orders can go to Canada too.

    Best for: Vermont-sewn plaid wool, including Tall sizes

  4. J.Crew

    4J.Crew

    jcrew.com
    • $89.50–$168.00
    • Similar price
    • Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)
    • Ships to US

    J.Crew lines up with Pendleton's cotton shirts rather than its wool ones. The Brushed cotton flannel workshirt ($128) costs $10 more than Pendleton's Burnside Cotton Flannel Shirt, and the Heavyweight chamois workshirt in Japanese cotton ($168) is the best seller to start with. The flannel is the cheaper test of the look, at $40 less.

    That chamois shirt is a straight price match. Pendleton's own Painted Hills Cotton Chamois Shirt is also $168, so you're choosing on fabric and fit, not cost. And if you just want a plain button-down, J.Crew's poplin shirts start at $89.50.

    Skip it if wool is the point. Taylor Stitch's wool-blend Shore Shirt costs the same $168.

    Best for: a cotton chamois or flannel workshirt under $170

  5. Taylor Stitch

    5Taylor Stitch

    taylorstitch.com
    • $118–$188
    • Similar price
    • XS–XXL; chest 36–46
    • Ships to US

    Taylor Stitch splits the difference between a cotton flannel and a Board Shirt. The Shore Shirt in Midnight Check Wool ($168) is 60% organic cotton and 40% wool, at $30 less than Pendleton's all-wool shirt.

    There's no pricey tier to wander into, since every shirt sits between $118 and $188. The Shore Shirt has a camp collar and two flap pockets, and it's made in China. If you'd rather start cheaper, the Jack in Blue Everyday Oxford ($118) is the lowest price in the range.

    US shipping is free on any order. But returns close after 21 days, a third of Pendleton's window, and sizes stop at XXL. If you wear Pendleton's Big or Tall sizes, Johnson Woolen Mills fits you better.

    Best for: half-wool plaid for $30 less than a Board Shirt

  6. 6Barbour

    barbour.com
    • $100–$290
    • Similar price
    • Chest 30–52 on the Bedale
    • Ships to US

    Barbour brings the tartan, at prices that mostly sit under Pendleton's. The Dunoon Tartan Authentic-Fit Long-Sleeved Shirt ($160) is the one to start with, at $38 under a Board Shirt. The Cliff Regular-Fit Long-Sleeved Shirt ($100) is the cheapest.

    Read the fit in the name before you buy. Barbour labels each shirt Tailored, Regular, Authentic-Fit or Relaxed. The same tartan can come in more than one cut (the Dunoon comes Authentic-Fit and Tailored), so check which one you're adding to the bag.

    The collaborations cost more. Paul Smith Loves Barbour is $200 and the Barbour x Norbit check shirt is $290. Free US shipping starts at $100, and returns run 30 days.

    Best for: a tartan shirt with a choice of cuts

  7. 3sixteen

    73sixteen

    3sixteen.com
    • $175–$285
    • Similar price
    • Waists 28–42
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia

    3sixteen is for someone who'd rather own one very good flannel than three cheap ones. The Crosscut Flannel ($285) has been in its line for more than 18 years, in a coarse, loosely woven Japanese cotton that's washed after sewing to take the shrinkage out.

    That's $87 more than a Board Shirt, and it's cotton, not wool. The money goes on the cloth and the details: a crossed back yoke and enamel-coated buttons that chip over time. Shirts here start at $175, and sizes stop at 2X.

    Returns are tight, with 10 days to send something back. If that window worries you, Faherty's Japanese flannel comes with 60. And if it's Japanese wool you want, Freenote's Dayton LS Harlequin is $340.

    Best for: one long-running Japanese flannel worth paying up for

  8. Faherty

    8Faherty

    fahertybrand.com
    • $148–$348
    • Similar price
    • XS–XXL
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK

    Faherty sells Japanese flannel for less than 3sixteen does. Its Japanese Flannel Workshirt ($248) uses flannel from Japan's Banshu region, in a relaxed fit with a 30-inch length. That's $37 under 3sixteen's Crosscut.

    The Laundered Oxford Shirt ($148) is the cheaper start, and the Sashiko Indigo Workshirt ($348) is the top of the range. Men's button-ups come in XS to XXL, and free shipping starts at $150, the same line as Pendleton's.

    Returns run 60 days, which matches Pendleton. Faherty also has more than 80 stores across the US, so you can try a relaxed fit on before you commit. It ships to Canada and the UK as well, which Pendleton doesn't.

    Best for: Japanese flannel you can try on in a store

  9. 9Uniqlo

    uniqlo.com
    • $49.90–$49.90
    • Cheaper
    • XXS–XL
    • Ships to US

    Uniqlo is the budget answer, and the gap is big. Its flannels are $49.90, so three of them cost less than one Board Shirt.

    The Flannel Checked Shirt is the one to start with, and the Tartan Check and Ombre Check versions cost the same. Pendleton's Burnside Cotton Flannel Shirt is $118, more than twice as much. That makes Uniqlo the low-risk way to find out whether you'll actually wear a plaid flannel before you spend on a wool one.

    Free shipping needs $99, so one shirt won't get you there, and returns run 30 days. If you want a step up without Pendleton's price, Schott's cotton flannel work shirts start at $80.

    Best for: three plaid flannels for the price of one Board Shirt

  10. Gitman

    10Gitman

    gitman.com
    • $250–$325
    • Pricier
    • S–XXL; collars 14½–22 (tall)
    • Ships to US

    Gitman is the pick for a flannel sewn in the US, if you don't mind paying past Pendleton's top price. Its shirts are made in Lafayette, Tennessee, and the Tan Flannel ($295) is cut from brushed flannel woven by Italy's Albini mill.

    Nothing is cheap here. The range starts at $250 with the Indigo Denim Shirt, so even the entry shirt costs more than a Board Shirt. What you get for it is fit: Tailored, Regular and Classic cuts, plus Big and Tall dress shirts, with collars from 14½ to 22.

    Standard US shipping is free. But you only get 14 days to ask for a return on a full-price shirt, so know your collar size first.

    Best for: a Tennessee-sewn flannel in your exact collar size

  11. Freenote Cloth

    11Freenote Cloth

    freenotecloth.com
    • $220–$360
    • Similar price
    • Waists 29–38
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia

    Freenote Cloth is the pick for a western shirt sewn in the US. The Sinclair Royal Blue Denim ($320) is its sawtooth western, in 10-ounce Japanese denim with rope-rimmed snaps.

    If you want wool, the Dayton LS Harlequin ($340) is a 70% wool blend from Japan with a camp collar. Both cost well over Pendleton's Snap-Front Western Canyon Shirt ($210), and even the cheapest shirt here, the Dayton Chambray, is $220.

    Returns are the catch. You get 7 days, the shortest window on this list, so check the size chart before you order. Shirts are cut S to XXL, so the Big and Tall sizes Pendleton and Johnson Woolen Mills carry aren't an option here.

    Best for: a US-sewn western shirt in Japanese denim or wool

  12. 12Schott NYC

    schottnyc.com
    • $75–$490
    • Similar price
    • XS–6XL; chest 32–54 on some
    • Ships to US

    Schott NYC has the cheapest wool-blend shirt on this list. The 7810 CPO Wool Shirt ($125) is a heavyweight 50% wool and poly blend with anchor buttons, a 30-inch back and two upper pockets.

    The plaid version, the 7310P ($155), is a 20-ounce wool blend, closer to the look of a Pendleton plaid. Both are imported, and the CPO goes up to 3XL. If you'd rather skip the wool, Schott's cotton flannel work shirts start at $80.

    Don't let the price range put you off. The $490 at the top is a cowhide western shirt, and the cloth shirts all sit near the bottom. Free US shipping starts at $100.

    Best for: a wool-blend CPO shirt for well under $150

How to choose

Start with what you like about the Board Shirt. If it's the wool, Johnson Woolen Mills sews plaid wool in Vermont for less, and Filson's Wool Guide Shirt costs a little more. Schott's CPO is the cheapest wool blend at $125, and Taylor Stitch's half-wool Shore Shirt is $168.

If it's the plaid and wool doesn't matter, Woolrich and Barbour both have shirts under $200, and Uniqlo is the $49.90 test run. For Japanese cloth, 3sixteen and Faherty make the flannels and Freenote does denim westerns. Pay up for Gitman if your collar size is hard to find. For Tall sizes, try Filson's Long or Johnson Woolen Mills' Tall shirts.

Questions

What is a Pendleton Board Shirt?

It's Pendleton's all-wool shirt: 100% pure virgin wool in a midweight fabric that resists water, odor and stains, with two flap chest pockets and a square bottom. It's $198 at full price.

How do you wash a Pendleton wool shirt?

The Board Shirt is machine washable. Wash it cold on a gentle cycle with no bleach, line dry it, and steam press it with a warm iron if it needs it.

Where do they make Pendleton shirts?

The fabric is woven in Pendleton's own mills in Oregon and Washington, from wool raised near its Pendleton, Oregon mill. The Board Shirt itself is assembled abroad, in El Salvador, from that US-made fabric.

What is an American brand of wool clothing?

Pendleton is one, and it weaves its own wool in Oregon and Washington. Johnson Woolen Mills goes further: it cuts and sews its wool shirts at its mill in Johnson, Vermont, a family business since 1842.