7 Brands Like Selkie for Fanciful, Romantic Party Dresses
By Ash · Last checked October 29, 2026 · We may earn a commission
You've picked out Selkie's Rainbow Puff Dress, seen the $290 price, and then found your size already gone. That happens a lot with a label that makes some pieces in runs of 15 to 20. These eight sell the dresses people reach for instead, from $12 secondhand finds to Brussels-made pieces at €1,960, and every one of them delivers to the US. Here's what each does best, and what it costs.
For reference, Selkie dresses runs $109–$1,500.
At a glance
| Brand | Dresses | Sizes | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| PrettyLittleThing | US 00–24 (plus, petite, tall) | petite, tall or plus lengths for $9.99 shipping | |
| Elliatt | $168–$870 | XXS–XXL | puff-sleeve occasion dresses at Selkie's prices, shipped from LA |
| Ester Manas | €190–€1,960 (about $212–$2,182) | XS–4XL (plus) | a handmade Brussels dress in sizes up to 4XL |
| Jen's Pirate Booty | $110–$375 | XS–XL | a bohemian maxi priced alongside a Selkie Puff Dress |
| Bardot | $139–$329 | US 0–12 | a cocktail dress with a month to send it back |
| Selfie Leslie | $59–$155 | XXS–4XL (plus) | new puff-sleeve dresses for under $100 |
| LIONESS | $55–$115 | XXS–XXL | a going-out dress under $115 with free US shipping |

1PrettyLittleThing
prettylittlething.us- US 00–24 (plus, petite, tall)
- Ships to US, Canada
PrettyLittleThing is the one to try when Selkie's fit is the problem rather than its look. It cuts dresses in petite, tall, plus and maternity ranges, from a US 00 to a 24, so you can choose a length as well as a size.
It's a Manchester label, part of the Boohoo Group, and US delivery is a flat $9.99 an order. Selkie charges $20 unless you spend $350, so on one dress PrettyLittleThing's delivery costs about half as much.
The catch is returns. You get 21 days, but $14.99 comes off the refund for each parcel, so order the size you're surest of. And the plus range stops at a 24, well short of Selkie's 6X.
Best for: petite, tall or plus lengths for $9.99 shipping
2Elliatt
elliatt.com- $168–$870
- Similar price
- XXS–XXL
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
Elliatt is the closest match here for Selkie's puff sleeves at Selkie's prices. The Floriana Puff Sleeve Mini Dress in Cornflower ($238) costs a little less than a Selkie Puff Dress. For bigger occasions, there's the Nathalie Puff Sleeve Gown in Pink Floral ($598).
It's a Sydney label, but US orders ship from its Los Angeles warehouse with no duties at checkout. Ground delivery is $15 whatever you spend. Its dresses run from $168 to $870, and the ones with puff sleeves in the name sit between $238 and $675, which is where to start.
Sizes stop at XXL, far short of Selkie's 6X. Returns close after 14 days and the postage back is yours, though US orders can swap sizes as an instant exchange. Need more room? Ester Manas goes to 4XL.
Best for: puff-sleeve occasion dresses at Selkie's prices, shipped from LA
3Ester Manas
estermanas.com- €190–€1,960 (about $212–$2,182)
- Similar price
- XS–4XL (plus)
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
Ester Manas is the pick if Selkie's size range is the reason you shop there. Its ready-to-wear is made for every body, in sizes from XS to 4XL, and the Butter Easy Slip Dress (€190, about $212) is the easiest way in.
The look is different, so know that before you go. These are ruched, sensual pieces made by hand in Brussels from deadstock and EU fabrics, not tulle and puff sleeves. The Signature dresses carry the price, like the Black Polka Dots Signature Dress (€1,250, about $1,392).
Prices are in euros, and US orders pay the duties on arrival, on top of €30 shipping (free over €350). Returns close after 14 days, with the label on you. For volume rather than ruching, Elliatt is closer.
Best for: a handmade Brussels dress in sizes up to 4XL
4Jen's Pirate Booty
jenspiratebooty.com- $110–$375
- Similar price
- XS–XL
- Ships to US, Canada, Australia
Jen's Pirate Booty is where to look if you like Selkie's romance but lean bohemian. It's a California label built around kaftans and kimonos, and its dresses run from the Countryside Mini Dress ($110) up to $375.
Start with the Lapis Maxi Dress ($285). It's priced right alongside Selkie's puff dresses, which run $249 to $335. Domestic shipping is free over $200, well under Selkie's $350 mark.
Two things to check first. Every return costs a $10 restocking fee plus the postage, inside 14 days, and sale pieces can't be refunded. Sizes run XS to XL, so for anything bigger, Selfie Leslie will serve you better.
Best for: a bohemian maxi priced alongside a Selkie Puff Dress
5Bardot
usa.bardot.com- $139–$329
- Similar price
- US 0–12
- Ships to US
Bardot is the one for Selkie's party side without the gown prices. Its US store has occasion and party dresses, like the Adrie Babydoll Mini Dress ($219), and the Natalya Mesh Midi Dress ($139) is about as low as it goes.
The returns are generous: 30 days on full-price pieces, for a refund, an exchange or credit. Orders ship from inside the US, $10 by ground or free over $200. That's a lower bar than Selkie's $350, and the Adrie clears it on its own.
The trade-off is size. It's cut on Australian sizing and stops at a US 12, a much narrower run than Selkie's XXS to 6X. For a bigger range at a lower price, Selfie Leslie goes to 4XL.
Best for: a cocktail dress with a month to send it back
6Selfie Leslie
selfieleslie.com- $59–$155
- Similar price
- XXS–4XL (plus)
- Ships to US, Canada, UK
Selfie Leslie is the place to go for new puff-sleeve dresses under $100. Start with its own Lovers Lane Lace Trim Puff Sleeve Dress ($89), or the SAINTS & SECRETS Hayden Puff Sleeve Eyelet Embroidery Dress ($69). Nothing in its dresses section goes past $155.
It's a California shop that mixes its own label with others, including MIKA & GALA and LIONESS. US shipping is free over $100, and returns run 30 days. Take store credit and you get the full amount back. A refund loses $9.75.
Most dresses come in XS to XL, with some up to 4XL, so check the size before you fall for one. And anything cut by 40% or more is final sale.
Best for: new puff-sleeve dresses for under $100
7LIONESS
lionessfashion.com- $55–$115
- Similar price
- XXS–XXL
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
LIONESS is the budget pick for a new going-out dress, and nothing in its US dress range costs more than $115. The Melrose Maxi Dress in Vintage Floral ($70) is the nearest it gets to Selkie's florals, and the Kiss & Tell Mini Dress ($55) is the cheapest way in.
It's an Australian label that takes its cues from luxury trends, and US orders ship free from its US warehouse. Returns run 30 days and cost nothing if you take credit or an exchange. A refund costs $15.
Don't come here for puff sleeves or tulle. These are minis and maxis in sizes XXS to XXL. If it's the puff sleeve you're after at this price, Selfie Leslie has far more of them.
Best for: a going-out dress under $115 with free US shipping
How to choose
Start with your budget. Under $100, Selfie Leslie has the most puff sleeves, and LIONESS keeps everything under $115. Around Selkie's puff-dress prices, Elliatt is the nearest match on puff sleeves, while Jen's Pirate Booty swaps them for bohemian maxis. Bardot covers cocktail dresses with a month to return them. If size is the sticking point, PrettyLittleThing has petite and tall lengths, and Ester Manas goes to 4XL in pieces made by hand in Brussels. Want a big-occasion gown? Elliatt's top out at $870, and the Ester Manas Signature dresses go higher.
Questions
Is Selkie fast fashion?
Not in the usual sense. Selkie cuts very small runs and pre-sells many of its best sellers, and some pieces have only 15 to 20 made. It does use polyester, though, so it isn't fully sustainable.
Where does Selkie ship from?
Most Selkie orders ship from China, which is why there's no expedited shipping. Delivery is $20, free over $350, and international orders usually arrive in 7 to 10 working days.
What is a Selkie dress?
It's a fanciful, romantic party dress from Selkie, the LA-designed label from Wildfox co-founder Kimberley Gordon. Its Puff Dresses run $249 to $335, and the whole range goes from $109 to $1,500 in sizes XXS to 6X.














