12 Stores Like Gap for Casual American Style
By Ash · Last checked October 29, 2026 · We may earn a commission
You know your size in Gap jeans and you like the easy, classic look of the basics. Now you want a second store to check, either to pay less or to trade up to something dressier. These 12 all sell women's jeans in the US, from $34.99 at Old Navy to $198 at J.Crew and Madewell. The closest matches come first.
For reference, Gap jeans runs $79.95–$99.95.
At a glance
| Brand | Jeans | Sizes | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Everlane | $88–$148 | XXS–XXXL; 00–16 | knowing what your jeans cost to make, at Gap money |
| Banana Republic | $120–$148 | 0–20, petite 00–12 and long 4–12 (petite, tall) | a dressier pair in the same Gap Inc. checkout |
| Levi's | trying on jeans in person at a denim company from 1853 | ||
| Abercrombie & Fitch | $80–$110 | Waists 26–38 | men's jeans at almost exactly Gap's prices |
| Old Navy | $34.99–$69.99 | 00–30; petite and tall (plus, petite, tall) | jeans under $55 in sizes up to 30 |
| Uniqlo | $49.90–$49.90 | XXS–XL | one flat price, with separate short and tall lengths |
| Toad&Co | $125–$130 | XS–XL | organic and recycled cotton denim with 90 days to return |
| J.Crew | $148–$198 | Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall) | petite or tall jeans when you're happy to pay more |
| Madewell | $148–$198 | Standard, Petite, Tall and Plus 14W–24W (1X–3X) (plus, petite, tall) | free hemming and plus sizes from a jeans-first store |
| Outerknown | $168–$198 | one straight-leg jean with a clear fiber story | |
| American Eagle | curvy-fit jeans with a 60-day return window | ||
| J.Crew Factory | Waists 24–35; petite and tall (petite, tall) | petite and tall J.Crew fits at discount prices |
1Everlane
everlane.com- $88–$148
- Similar price
- XXS–XXXL; 00–16
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
Everlane is the closest match on price, and the one to pick if you'd like to know what your jeans cost to make. The Way-High Curve Jean ($88) comes in under most of Gap's $89.95 pairs, and the Baggy Barrel-Leg Jean ($128) is where the range climbs.
It publishes the cost of materials, labor and transport behind its products, so you can see where the money goes. The Way-High Curve also comes in 27-inch and 29-inch inseams, which saves a trip to the tailor if you're shorter.
The catch is the small fees. Standard shipping is $8 and mail returns cost $7, though returns in its stores are free. Most styles stop at a 33 waist, with 34 and 35 on a few, so if you wear Gap's top sizes, stay with Gap or go to Old Navy.
Best for: knowing what your jeans cost to make, at Gap money
2Banana Republic
bananarepublic.gap.com- $120–$148
- Pricier
- 0–20, petite 00–12 and long 4–12 (petite, tall)
- Ships to US
Banana Republic is Gap's dressier sibling, and the move if you want the same checkout with a more polished pair. The Icon Classic Wide-Leg Jean ($130) is typical, and the High-Rise 90S Straight Jean ($120) is the cheapest way in.
Because both belong to Gap Inc., a Gap pair and a Banana Republic pair go in one shopping bag, and rewards members get free shipping over $50 at both. Sizes run 0 to 20, with petite from 00 and long lengths from 4. It started in 1978 as a travel outfitter and still leads with cashmere and linen, so denim is a side line here.
One thing to know before you mix brands in an order. Store returns go back only to the brand you bought from, so Banana Republic jeans can't go back to a Gap store.
Best for: a dressier pair in the same Gap Inc. checkout
3Levi's
levi.comLevi's is the pick if denim is the reason you shop Gap. It's the older San Francisco jeans company, founded there in 1853, a long way ahead of Gap's start in the same city in 1969. Today it makes jeans and casual wear for men, women and kids, so like Gap it covers the basics around the denim too.
The practical route here is a store. Levi's has US stores in 40 states, so you can try a few cuts back to back instead of ordering three sizes and sending two back.
If you'd rather shop online at a price you can compare, Everlane and Abercrombie & Fitch sit closest to Gap's $89.95.
Best for: trying on jeans in person at a denim company from 1853

4Abercrombie & Fitch
abercrombie.com- $80–$110
- Similar price
- Waists 26–38
- Ships to US, Canada
Abercrombie & Fitch lands almost exactly on Gap's prices. Its men's jeans start at $80 for the 90s Straight and Relaxed Straight and top out at $110 for the Relaxed Workwear Jean, against Gap's $79.95 to $99.95.
For women, the jeans are grouped by leg shape, from wide and loose through bootcut and flare to straight and skinny, which makes it quick to shop by silhouette. Men's waists run 26 to 38. It goes back to 1892 in Manhattan and is now based in Ohio.
The trade-off is shipping. It's free only over $99, roughly double Gap's $50 bar for rewards members. If one pair is all you need, Gap or Old Navy gets you there for less.
Best for: men's jeans at almost exactly Gap's prices
6Uniqlo
uniqlo.com- $49.90–$49.90
- Cheaper
- XXS–XL
- Ships to US
Uniqlo is the pick for simple jeans at one flat price. Its regular women's jeans are $49.90 across the board, from the Barrel Jeans to the EZY Wide Straight Jeans, about $30 under Gap's lowest.
Start with the Baggy Barrel Jeans ($49.90) if length is your problem, because they come in separate Short and Tall versions. That's the job Gap's petite and tall sections do, for less money.
But the terms are stricter than Gap's. Free shipping starts at $99, though in-store pickup is free, and online orders can't be returned in a store, so you'll pay return postage unless the item was wrong. With 86 US stores, buying in person sidesteps both.
Best for: one flat price, with separate short and tall lengths

7Toad&Co
toadandco.com- $125–$130
- Pricier
- XS–XL
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
Toad&Co is the one for lower-impact denim at a price a step above Gap. The Tamarack Straight Jean ($125) and Tamarack Wide Leg Jean ($130) are cut from organic and recycled cotton denim with a little stretch.
It's a California brand and a certified B Corp, and the Tamarack runs from size 0 to 18. Toad&Co itself suggests sizing up on the straight style, so start a size bigger than your Gap pair. Returns get 90 days, three times Gap's window, though refunds carry a $7 handling fee.
Free shipping doesn't start until $150, though. If you want a cleaner materials story closer to Gap's price, Everlane starts at $88.
Best for: organic and recycled cotton denim with 90 days to return

8J.Crew
jcrew.com- $148–$198
- Pricier
- Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)
- Ships to US
J.Crew is the step up for the same classic look, and the pick if petite or tall lengths are why you shop Gap. Most of its jeans come in Classic, Petite and Tall, with waists from 23 to 37, and the barrel and slim-wide styles are $158.
Expect $148 to $198, so even the cheapest pair costs more than Gap's priciest. Standard shipping is $7, and it's free for J.Crew Rewards members on qualifying orders.
Returns run 30 days, but $7.50 comes off your refund if you use the prepaid label. If you like the fits and not the price, J.Crew Factory offers the same Classic, Petite and Tall split at discount prices.
Best for: petite or tall jeans when you're happy to pay more
9Madewell
madewell.com- $148–$198
- Pricier
- Standard, Petite, Tall and Plus 14W–24W (1X–3X) (plus, petite, tall)
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
Madewell is the jeans-first store on this list, a brand whose story begins with denim. Most of its jeans are $148, about $58 more than a typical Gap pair, with a few at $158 to $198.
The useful part is the fit help. Insiders get free hemming in its stores, so a pair that's right everywhere but the length is an easy fix. Fits cover petite, tall, curvy and plus sizes from 14W to 24W.
Shipping is the sticking point. It's free only for signed-in Insiders, and everyone else pays $5 or $7 with no order minimum that unlocks it. Returns get 30 days, the same as Gap.
Best for: free hemming and plus sizes from a jeans-first store
10Outerknown
outerknown.com- $168–$198
- Pricier
- Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia
Outerknown is for paying more for a jean with a clear fiber story. Its one women's jean, The Scout Straight Jean ($168), sits next to unisex cuts like the Beachcomber Relaxed Jean ($168) and the Craftsman Jean ($198).
98% of its fibers count as preferred fibers, and the Fair Labor Association accredited its compliance program in 2015. Full-price returns are free within 30 days, and US shipping is free over $125.
Choice is the limit. With a single women's style, it only works if a straight leg is what you want. Most of its denim is men's and unisex, so read the size chart on those cuts. For straight and wide legs at a lower price, Toad&Co starts at $125.
Best for: one straight-leg jean with a clear fiber story

11American Eagle
ae.com- Ships to US
American Eagle is the pick if you want a jeans-led mall store with a long return window. Its homepage leads with jeans, and several cuts come in a Curvy Fit, like the AE Curvy High-Waisted Stovepipe Jean.
Returns run 60 days, twice Gap's 30, which gives you longer to decide on a fit. That matters most if you're trying a Curvy cut for the first time. Online returns cost $5 unless you're a Real Rewards Level 3 member or cardholder.
Free shipping starts higher, though, at $75 against Gap's $50 for rewards members, and orders below that pay $7.95. It works best when you're buying two pairs at once.
Best for: curvy-fit jeans with a 60-day return window

12J.Crew Factory
factory.jcrew.com- Waists 24–35; petite and tall (petite, tall)
- Ships to US, Canada
J.Crew Factory is the discount route to J.Crew's fits, and the answer if you want Gap's petite and tall choice on a tighter budget. Its women's jeans come in Classic, Petite and Tall, plus a Curvy section, with waists from 25 to 35 and petite from 24. That's the same regular, petite and tall split Gap uses, so your usual length carries over.
Shipping is $7, or free over $99. Returns get 30 days, with $7.50 off for the prepaid label, and online orders can go back to a Factory store. Just not a J.Crew one, since the two take returns separately.
No plus sizes are listed. If you need them, Madewell or Old Navy is the better fit.
Best for: petite and tall J.Crew fits at discount prices
How to choose
If you like Gap and only want to pay less, Old Navy is the easy move, with the same checkout and sizes up to 30. Uniqlo is the other one, at $49.90 a pair. For the same money as Gap, Everlane and Abercrombie & Fitch sit closest. To trade up, Banana Republic keeps you inside Gap Inc., while J.Crew and Madewell cost more but help with length, through petite and tall cuts or free hemming. J.Crew Factory is the cheaper way into those J.Crew fits. For lower-impact denim, start with Toad&Co, then Outerknown. American Eagle wins on returns, and Levi's is the one to try on in a store.
Questions
Can you return Gap items to Old Navy?
No. Gap Inc. takes in-store returns and exchanges only at the brand you bought from, so jeans from Gap.com or a Gap store can't go back to an Old Navy store.
What are the four Gap brands?
Gap Inc. owns Old Navy, Gap, Banana Republic and Athleta. Online, all four share one shopping bag, so you can buy from them in a single order.
Is Gap luxury clothing?
No. Gap Inc. calls it a brand of casual American style, and most of its regular women's jeans are $89.95. Banana Republic is the company's dressier label, with jeans from $120.





