STYLODEX

10 Stores Like Old Navy for Affordable Family Clothing

By Ash · Last checked October 29, 2026 · We may earn a commission

You've got Old Navy jeans that fit, at a price you don't have to think about. Now you want a second store to check, whether that means paying less or paying a bit more for a bigger denim name. These ten sell women's jeans from $28 at Target to $225 at Alex Mill, and every one ships to US addresses. The closest matches come first.

For reference, Old Navy jeans runs $34.99–$69.99.

At a glance

BrandJeansSizesBest for
Gap$79.95–$99.95000–20; petite and tall (petite, tall)trading up from Old Navy without leaving the same checkout
Target$28.00–$74.99jeans under $40 with a full year to return them
Banana Republic$120–$1480–20, petite 00–12 and long 4–12 (petite, tall)dressier jeans in petite and long lengths
J.Crew$148–$198Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)petite or tall jeans at a step-up price
American Eaglejeans-first shopping with a 60-day return window
Nordstrom Rack$39.97–$79.9700–28W, petite and plus; waists 23–36 (plus, petite)Levi's and Madewell jeans at Old Navy prices
Aeropostale$64.95–$69.95000–20, XXS–XXL, short and long lengths; waists 26–46low-rise baggy jeans with free shipping from $25
Everlane$88–$148XXS–XXXL; 00–16knowing what your jeans cost to make
Madewell$148–$198Standard, Petite, Tall and Plus 14W–24W (1X–3X) (plus, petite, tall)plus, petite or tall denim with free in-store hemming
Alex Mill$225–$225XS–XL; XXS and XXL on some stylesone rigid, all-cotton pair instead of three stretchy ones
  1. 1Gap

    gap.com
    • $79.95–$99.95
    • Pricier
    • 000–20; petite and tall (petite, tall)
    • Ships to US

    Gap is the obvious next stop, because it's Old Navy's sibling inside Gap Inc. and a brand whose history starts with denim. Most of its women's jeans are $89.95, like the High Rise '70s Flare Jeans ($89.95) and The Hailey Extra Baggy Jean ($89.95).

    Here's the useful part. Old Navy, Gap and Banana Republic share one shopping bag online, so you can put a $45 Old Navy pair next to a Gap one and check out once. The terms match too: rewards members get free shipping over $50, and returns stay open for 30 days. Petite fits get their own section, which makes shorter lengths easy to find.

    The catch is price. Gap's regular jeans start at $79.95, above the most Old Navy charges for any pair.

    Best for: trading up from Old Navy without leaving the same checkout

  2. 2Target

    target.com
    • $28.00–$74.99
    • Similar price
    • Ships to US

    Target is where to go if Old Navy's prices are the main draw, because its own denim labels start lower. Universal Thread's High-Rise Wide Leg Jeans ($28) and Wild Fable's Low-Rise Straight Leg Jeans ($28) come in about $7 under Old Navy's cheapest regular pair.

    Start with Universal Thread if you want classic fits. It covers boyfriend, vintage straight and palazzo styles, none over $40. Wild Fable leans low-rise and baggy. And if you'd rather pay for the name, Levi's sits in the same section at $74.99.

    Returns are the quiet win. Most items get 90 days, and Target's own brands get a full year with a receipt. With more than 2,000 US stores, trying a pair on first is easy.

    Best for: jeans under $40 with a full year to return them

  3. 3Banana Republic

    bananarepublic.gap.com
    • $120–$148
    • Pricier
    • 0–20, petite 00–12 and long 4–12 (petite, tall)
    • Ships to US

    Banana Republic is the dressier end of the Old Navy family, and its jeans cost well over twice what most Old Navy pairs do. The Icon Classic Wide-Leg Jean ($130) is typical, and the High-Rise 90S Straight Jean ($120) is the cheapest way in.

    It started in 1978 as a travel outfitter, and the store now leads with cashmere, leather and linen, so denim is a side line here rather than the main event. Sizes run 0 to 20, with petite from 00 and long lengths from 4. Because it's Gap Inc., it goes in the same shopping bag as an Old Navy order.

    The trade-off is size range. Old Navy goes up to a 30 and Banana Republic stops at 20, so for anything bigger, stay with Old Navy.

    Best for: dressier jeans in petite and long lengths

  4. J.Crew

    4J.Crew

    jcrew.com
    • $148–$198
    • Pricier
    • Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)
    • Ships to US

    J.Crew is the pick if you like Old Navy's petite and tall options and want a pricier pair to go with them. Most of its jeans come in Classic, Petite and Tall, with waists from 23 to 37, and the barrel and slim-wide styles sit at $158.

    That makes it an easy step up for anyone shorter or taller than average, since the length is offered across most styles rather than on a few. Expect $148 to $198, so this is a pair you buy once, not three of.

    Two things to know before ordering. Returns run 30 days, but $7.50 comes off your refund if you use the prepaid label. Rewards members get free standard shipping, and everyone else pays $7.

    Best for: petite or tall jeans at a step-up price

  5. American Eagle

    5American Eagle

    ae.com
    • Ships to US

    American Eagle is the closest thing to Old Navy for a store that puts jeans first, right down to its homepage. If Old Navy's curvy styles work for you, look at AE's Curvy Fit, since both stores cut a curvy version of their main fits.

    The return window is the standout: 60 days for a full refund, twice Old Navy's 30. Online returns cost $5 unless you're a top-tier rewards member or cardholder. Shipping is free from $75, which is $25 more than Old Navy asks of its members.

    If you mostly order one pair at a time, that $75 bar matters. Aeropostale ships free from $25, so it's the better fit for small orders.

    Best for: jeans-first shopping with a 60-day return window

  6. 6Nordstrom Rack

    nordstromrack.com
    • $39.97–$79.97
    • Similar price
    • 00–28W, petite and plus; waists 23–36 (plus, petite)
    • Ships to US

    Nordstrom Rack is how you get Old Navy prices on bigger denim names. Its jeans mostly land between $40 and $80, close to Old Navy's own range, but the labels are names like Levi's and Madewell. The Levi's 501 '90s High Waist Straight Leg Jeans ($49.97) are a good example, listed against a comparable value of $110.

    Sizes run from 00 to 28W, with petite and plus filters, so the spread is close to Old Navy's. Shipping is free over $89, and you've got 40 days to send things back.

    Mail returns cost $9.95 per label. Online orders go back free to any Nordstrom or Rack store, so if there's one near you, return in person.

    Best for: Levi's and Madewell jeans at Old Navy prices

  7. 7Aeropostale

    aeropostale.com
    • $64.95–$69.95
    • Similar price
    • 000–20, XXS–XXL, short and long lengths; waists 26–46
    • Ships to US

    Aeropostale is the louder, younger take on Old Navy's denim wall, with most pairs at $64.95. That's near the top of Old Navy's range, and the styling is the difference: low-rise and super low-rise baggy fits, plus embellished pairs with rhinestone hearts or stars at $69.95.

    Sizes start at 000 and go to 20, with short and long lengths. That helps if you're petite or tall and still want the baggy look. Jeans share the homepage with hoodies and graphic tees, so it's an easy place to round out a casual order. Shipping is free from just $25, the lowest bar on this list.

    If you want a similar price without the low-rise styling, Target's Universal Thread costs less.

    Best for: low-rise baggy jeans with free shipping from $25

  8. 8Everlane

    everlane.com
    • $88–$148
    • Pricier
    • XXS–XXXL; 00–16
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia

    Everlane is for the Old Navy shopper who wants to know what a pair costs to make. It publishes the cost breakdown behind its products, and its jeans start with The Way-High Curve Jean ($88), which comes in two inseam lengths.

    At the top end, the W Heavyweight Low Rise Relaxed Boot Flare Jean ($148) is the one to look at if you want heavier denim. Sizes run 00 to 16, so the range is a lot narrower than Old Navy's 00 to 30.

    Returns are open for 30 days from shipping. Mail-in returns cost $7, store returns are free, and standard US shipping is $8. It also ships to Canada, the UK and Australia, which helps if you're buying for someone abroad.

    Best for: knowing what your jeans cost to make

  9. 9Madewell

    madewell.com
    • $148–$198
    • Pricier
    • Standard, Petite, Tall and Plus 14W–24W (1X–3X) (plus, petite, tall)
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia

    Madewell is the denim specialist here, and if you've outgrown Old Navy's fits rather than its prices, start with it. Most pairs are $148, and it's a denim brand first, with a story that begins with jeans.

    The useful extra is in its stores, where Insiders get free hemming. That takes the guesswork out of lengths. Fits cover petite, tall, curvy and plus sizes 14W to 24W. It's J.Crew's sister brand, and the two price their jeans the same, $148 to $198.

    Shipping is free only for signed-in Insiders, so join before you order. Returns run 30 days, and it ships to Canada, the UK and Australia too. If $148 is more than you want to spend, Everlane's jeans start at $88.

    Best for: plus, petite or tall denim with free in-store hemming

  10. Alex Mill

    10Alex Mill

    alexmill.com
    • $225–$225
    • Pricier
    • XS–XL; XXS and XXL on some styles
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia

    Alex Mill is the splurge, for when you'd rather own one rigid, all-cotton pair than three stretchy ones. Every pair is $225, and the Jane Mid-rise Straight Jean ($225) is the classic shape, in 14 oz denim with no stretch at all.

    Two of its styles, the Bessette and the Violet, are made in Los Angeles. That's a real difference from everything else here, and so is the size run. Waists go from 24 to 32, much shorter than Old Navy's spread.

    Returns close after 21 days, quicker than Old Navy's 30. Shipping is free from $200, so one pair gets you there. Its own motto is timeless, not trendy, and it has two stores in New York if you'd rather try the fit first.

    Best for: one rigid, all-cotton pair instead of three stretchy ones

How to choose

If price is why you shop Old Navy, start at Target for own-label pairs from $28, or Nordstrom Rack for Levi's and Madewell in the same $40 to $80 band. If you want bigger denim names with the same checkout, Gap is the next step and Banana Republic the one after it. For petite and tall lengths, look at J.Crew first, then Madewell, which adds plus sizes and free hemming. American Eagle wins on returns, and Aeropostale on cheap shipping. And if you'd rather own one serious pair, Everlane shows you what it costs to make, while Alex Mill sells rigid all-cotton jeans at $225.

Questions

Who owns Old Navy?

Gap Inc. owns Old Navy, along with Gap and Banana Republic, and the three share one shopping bag online. Old Navy opened its first store in Colma, California, in 1994.

What is Old Navy's return policy?

You get 30 days from delivery or purchase, and returns are free by mail with a prepaid label or in store. Some rewards members get up to 45 days, and All-Access cardholders up to 60. Final sale items can't go back.

Does Old Navy have free shipping?

Yes, for rewards members on orders of $50 or more. Members' orders under $50 ship for $7, and orders from nonmembers ship for $9.