STYLODEX

13 Stores Like Tuckernuck for Colorful, Classic Dresses

By Ash · Last checked October 29, 2026 · We may earn a commission

You've had a Tuckernuck dress in your basket for a week, and it's $298. Or it sold out in your size. Either way, you want that bright, polished look from somewhere else. We start with a boutique that mixes labels the way Tuckernuck does, then the preppy brands at similar prices, and finish with dresses for under $70.

For reference, Tuckernuck dresses runs $88–$4,195.

At a glance

BrandDressesSizesBest for
Avara$68–$138XXS–XXXLa Tuckernuck-style mix of labels for under $140
J.Crew$148–$298Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)a polished workday dress at Tuckernuck's own-label prices
Quince$59.90–$159.90XS–XL; 1X–3X on some styles (plus)silk dresses under $120 with a year to return them
Hill House Home$128–$498XXXS–4XL; numeric 00–16the full Nap Dress range, not just Tuckernuck's edit
Jude Connally$160–$298XS–XXLAmerican-made dresses at Tuckernuck's own-label prices
Sail to Sable$168–$288XXS–XXXLpreppy prints in sizes up to XXXL
Mahi Gold$175–$278XXS–XLa packable print dress for a beach trip
Southern Tide$138–$228XS–XLa sporty polo-style dress with free 30-day returns
Draper James$98–$188XS–XXL, 0–14 and plus 1X–3X, 16X–24XSouthern prints in plus sizes up to 24X
Cabana Life$74–$170XS–XL; plus 1X–3Xa beach dress with UPF 50+ sun protection
Petal & Pup$59–$149XXS–XXL; numeric 0–16a trend-led dress for under $110
Mary Square$55–$132XS–XL; plus 1X–2Xa printed everyday dress for under $100
RIHOAS$30–$66XS–XL; US 0–8a retro-style dress for under $50
  1. Avara

    1Avara

    shopavara.com
    • $68–$138
    • Similar price
    • XXS–XXXL
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Avara is the closest thing to Tuckernuck's mix of labels, at about half the price. It's a Dallas boutique that stocks English Factory, Fate and SugarLips side by side, and its regular-price dresses run from $68 to $138. The Dark Denim Midi Dress from Flying Tomato ($88) is a fair place to start.

    Most dresses sit at $88 or $98, so one dress plus the $5 shipping still costs less than Tuckernuck's cheapest own-label dress. Orders over $100 ship free. Sizes run XXS to XXXL.

    The catch is returns. You get the same 21 days as Tuckernuck, but a mailed return costs $6.95 and anything bought on sale is final. If you want free returns, Quince is the safer bet.

    Best for: a Tuckernuck-style mix of labels for under $140

  2. J.Crew

    2J.Crew

    jcrew.com
    • $148–$298
    • Similar price
    • Waists 23–37 in Classic, Petite and Tall (petite, tall)
    • Ships to US

    J.Crew is where to go if you like Tuckernuck's polished side more than its prints. Its regular-price dresses run $148 to $298, the same band as Tuckernuck's own label, and the Parc dress in four-season stretch ($198) is the easy one to start with.

    The cheapest way in is the Gwyneth slip dress in a cupro blend ($148), with the Natasha slip dress ($178) just above it. Both work for an evening out without an event-dress price.

    Returns run 30 days, longer than Tuckernuck's 21, though the prepaid label takes $7.50 off your refund. Shipping is $7 unless you're a J.Crew Rewards member. Quince charges nothing to ship either way, if that matters more.

    Best for: a polished workday dress at Tuckernuck's own-label prices

  3. Quince

    3Quince

    quince.com
    • $59.90–$159.90
    • Similar price
    • XS–XL; 1X–3X on some styles (plus)
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Quince is the pick when the fabric matters more than the label. The 100% Washable Silk Maxi Slip Dress ($114.90) costs less than Tuckernuck's cheapest own-label dress, and the ribbed cotton cashmere midi dresses start at $59.90. The Tencel Modal knit dresses are $60 too, if you want something for every week.

    Those prices come from selling factory-direct, with no wholesalers in between. Shipping is always free, and most things can go back free within 365 days. So ordering two sizes and returning one costs you nothing.

    Sizes are the catch. Most styles stop at XL, with 1X to 3X on only some of them, so Draper James is the better start if you need a plus size.

    Best for: silk dresses under $120 with a year to return them

  4. 4Hill House Home

    hillhousehome.com
    • $128–$498
    • Similar price
    • XXXS–4XL; numeric 00–16
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Hill House Home is the obvious next stop, because Tuckernuck already stocks it. Buying direct gets you the whole Nap Dress range rather than Tuckernuck's edit of it, and the Ellie Nap Dress ($178) is the one to start with.

    The brand launched with bedding in 2016 and added clothes later, and the Nap Dress is still what it's known for. Prices run from $128 to $498, and most dresses sit between $228 and $298, right where Tuckernuck's own label lives. Sizes are wide, from XXXS to 4XL.

    Watch the returns. You get 15 days, and $12 comes off your refund unless you pay $3.79 for Checkout+ when you order. Free shipping starts at $250. Draper James gives you a few more days to decide.

    Best for: the full Nap Dress range, not just Tuckernuck's edit

  5. 5Jude Connally

    judeconnally.com
    • $160–$298
    • Similar price
    • XS–XXL
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Jude Connally makes its dresses in the USA, and that's the reason to pick it over the cheaper brands here. Prices run $160 to $298, close to Tuckernuck's own label, and the Alexia Dress in Jude Cloth ($198) is a good first order.

    Jude Cloth is the house fabric, and most of the dresses come in it, in regular, lightweight and brushed versions. Learn that name and you'll know what you're getting across styles. Standard shipping is free in the US.

    Returns are tight, though. You get 14 days, and the return label costs $8. If you'd rather have time to try things on, Southern Tide gives you 30 days and free returns.

    Best for: American-made dresses at Tuckernuck's own-label prices

  6. Sail to Sable

    6Sail to Sable

    sailtosable.com
    • $168–$288
    • Similar price
    • XXS–XXXL
    • Ships to US

    Sail to Sable sums up its own look as chic meets preppy, which is the Tuckernuck brief in three words. Its regular-price dresses run $168 to $288, and the long-sleeve tunic flare dresses ($198) come in plaids and block prints.

    Sizes go from XXS to XXXL, so it covers more sizes than Mahi Gold, which stops at XL. If you like Tuckernuck's shirt dresses, try the Brown & White Gingham Embroidered Shirt Dress ($188).

    Free shipping only starts at $500, so budget for postage on a single dress. Full-price returns get a refund within 15 days, then store credit up to 30. Orders ship from its New Jersey warehouse, and anything from the SALE section is final.

    Best for: preppy prints in sizes up to XXXL

  7. Mahi Gold

    7Mahi Gold

    mahigold.com
    • $175–$278
    • Similar price
    • XXS–XL
    • Ships to US

    Mahi Gold is the pick for the coastal, print-heavy side of Tuckernuck. It makes beach and resort dresses in its own prints, in the USA whenever possible, and the Bimini Dress ($190) is a good first one.

    Prints are the point here. A handful of shapes, like the Charleston ($195) and the Annie, each come in a long list of prints, so once you know your shape you can shop by pattern. Every dress sits between $175 and $278, and orders over $150 ship free.

    Sizes stop at XL, though. Returns run 15 days with an $8 handling charge, while exchanges are free. Sail to Sable goes up to XXXL with the same preppy prints.

    Best for: a packable print dress for a beach trip

  8. Southern Tide

    8Southern Tide

    southerntide.com
    • $138–$228
    • Similar price
    • XS–XL
    • Ships to US

    Southern Tide suits you if you like Tuckernuck's sporty side, the polo dresses and Tnuck Sport. The brand started in 2006 with a polo shirt, and the Bailee Short Sleeve Performance Dress ($148) carries that into a dress. It's still based in Greenville, South Carolina, where it began.

    Its dress range is small and runs $138 to $228, so it's quick to shop in one sitting. Returns are the best part. You get 30 days and they're free, nine more than Tuckernuck gives you. Orders over $150 ship free.

    It only ships within the US, and sizes stop at XL. For a wider size range in the same preppy lane, Draper James goes up to 24X.

    Best for: a sporty polo-style dress with free 30-day returns

  9. 9Draper James

    draperjames.com
    • $98–$188
    • Similar price
    • XS–XXL, 0–14 and plus 1X–3X, 16X–24X
    • Ships to US

    Draper James is the one to try if you need a plus size. Reese Witherspoon's Southern-inspired label cuts its dresses in XS to XXL, 0 to 14 and plus sizes up to 24X. The Layla Mini Dress in Windsor Foulard ($158) shows off its prints.

    Full-price dresses run $98 to $188, so it mostly undercuts Tuckernuck's own label. Much of the dress range sits in the sale section, and one rule matters there. Prices ending in .98 are final sale.

    You get 20 days for returns. A mailed return costs $6.95, but it's free at a Happy Returns bar or the Nashville store. It only ships within the US, and orders ship free from $150.

    Best for: Southern prints in plus sizes up to 24X

  10. Cabana Life

    10Cabana Life

    cabanalife.com
    • $74–$170
    • Similar price
    • XS–XL; plus 1X–3X
    • Ships to US

    Cabana Life is for Tuckernuck's resort dresses with sun protection built in. Everything it makes is UPF 50+, so a beach-day dress doubles as cover from the sun. The shift dresses are the core of the range, and the White Leaf Textured Shift Dress ($112) is an easy first buy.

    Regular prices run $74 to $170, below Mahi Gold's, and sizes go up to 3X. The Delray Short Sleeve Shift Dress ($116) is the one with sleeves, if you want more cover. Returns are 30 days.

    Free shipping doesn't start until $195, though, so one dress will cost you postage. If you only want the print and not the UPF, Mahi Gold ships free from $150.

    Best for: a beach dress with UPF 50+ sun protection

  11. Petal & Pup

    11Petal & Pup

    petalandpup.com
    • $59–$149
    • Similar price
    • XXS–XXL; numeric 0–16
    • Ships to US, Canada

    Petal & Pup is the pick for a new dress under $110 without much risk. It's an Australian label with a US store that charges in dollars, and its dresses run $59 to $149, most between $89 and $109. The Avina Maxi Dress ($79) is a good place to start.

    Orders over $80 ship free, so most single dresses clear the line, and standard US delivery takes 3 to 6 business days. Returns run 30 days, but $9.95 comes off a refund, so exchange if you can.

    It's younger and more trend-led than Tuckernuck. It also has the biggest dress range on this list, so filter by length before you start scrolling.

    Best for: a trend-led dress for under $110

  12. Mary Square

    12Mary Square

    marysquare.com
    • $55–$132
    • Similar price
    • XS–XL; plus 1X–2X
    • Ships to US

    Mary Square is a good stop for an everyday dress under $135. The Cameron Dress ($90) comes in several of its own prints, and the Carolina T-Shirt Dress ($55) is the cheapest way in.

    It's a women-owned brand that sells pajamas and gifts too, and the T-shirt dresses make it more weekend than wedding guest. Sizes run XS to XL, plus 1X and 2X.

    Plan ahead on delivery. Orders ship from North Carolina and take 7 to 10 days, slower than Petal & Pup's 3 to 6. A refund loses $7.95, while store credit adds $5, so it pays to be sure of your size. Picking an exchange or store credit also avoids the return shipping fee.

    Best for: a printed everyday dress for under $100

  13. 13RIHOAS

    rihoas.com
    • $30–$66
    • Cheaper
    • XS–XL; US 0–8
    • Ships to US, Canada, UK, Australia

    RIHOAS is the cheapest stop on this list by a distance, with every full-price dress between $30 and $66. It calls its style elegant with retro charm, and the Blue Floral Ruched Slip Midi Dress ($39) is typical of it.

    Two dresses usually clear the $69 free-shipping line. Standard delivery to the US takes 7 to 12 days, the slowest here, and sizes stop at XL. It ships to Canada, the UK and Australia as well.

    Returns are the trade-off. You have 14 days to ask, and you pay to send things back unless they arrive faulty. So buy what you'd keep at that price, and go to Quince if you want cheap and free returns.

    Best for: a retro-style dress for under $50

How to choose

Start with what you shop Tuckernuck for. If it's the mix of labels, Avara is the closest store at about half the price. For dresses at Tuckernuck's own-label prices, J.Crew, Hill House Home and Jude Connally all sit around $150 to $300, and Jude Connally makes its dresses in the USA. Want prints for a trip? Go to Mahi Gold or Sail to Sable, or Cabana Life if you need sun protection. Draper James is the start for plus sizes. On a budget, Quince gives you silk with free returns, while Petal & Pup and RIHOAS keep most dresses under $110 and $70.

Questions

What is Tuckernuck?

Tuckernuck is a Washington, DC store that sells its own labels, including Tuckernuck, Tnuck Sport and Tnuck Beach, next to outside designers such as Ulla Johnson and Barbour. Dresses are what it's best known for.

Does Tuckernuck have stores?

Yes. Tuckernuck has stores on Madison Avenue in New York, on Wisconsin Avenue in Washington, DC, and on Centre Street in Nantucket, with a fourth on the way.

Where is Tuckernuck based?

Washington, DC. It started there in 2012, when its founders, a group of family and friends, couldn't find boutiques they loved close to home.

What is Tuckernuck's return policy?

You have 21 days from delivery to return or exchange, and US returns are free. Size exchanges are free too, and you can take store credit instead of a refund. Final Sale and monogrammed items can't go back.